Sunday, June 16, 2024

Multiple organizations issue joint statement on legislative efforts to restrict education

| June 16, 2021 9:13 AM

We, the undersigned associations and organizations, state our firm opposition to a spate of legislative proposals being introduced across the country that target academic lessons, presentations, and discussions of racism and related issues in American history in schools, colleges and universities. These efforts have taken varied shape in at least 20 states; but often the legislation aims to prohibit or impede the teaching and education of students concerning what are termed “divisive concepts.” These divisive concepts as defined in numerous bills are a litany of vague and indefinite buzzwords and phrases including, for example, “that any individual should feel or be made to feel discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological or emotional distress on account of that individual's race or sex.” These legislative efforts are deeply troubling for numerous reasons.

First, these bills risk infringing on the right of faculty to teach and of students to learn. The clear goal of these efforts is to suppress teaching and learning about the role of racism in the history of the United States. Purportedly, any examination of racism in this country’s classrooms might cause some students “discomfort” because it is an uncomfortable and complicated subject. But the ideal of informed citizenship necessitates an educated public. Educators must provide an accurate view of the past in order to better prepare students for community participation and robust civic engagement. Suppressing or watering down discussion of “divisive concepts” in educational institutions deprives students of opportunities to discuss and foster solutions to social division and injustice. Legislation cannot erase “concepts” or history; it can, however, diminish educators’ ability to help students address facts in an honest and open environment capable of nourishing intellectual exploration. Educators owe students a clear-eyed, nuanced, and frank delivery of history, so that they can learn, grow, and confront the issues of the day, not hew to some state-ordered ideology.

Second, these legislative efforts seek to substitute political mandates for the considered judgment of professional educators, hindering students’ ability to learn and engage in critical thinking across differences and disagreements. These regulations constitute an inappropriate attempt to transfer responsibility for the evaluation of a curriculum and subject matter from educators to elected officials. The purpose of education is to serve the common good by promoting open inquiry and advancing human knowledge. Politicians in a democratic society should not manipulate public school curricula to advance partisan or ideological aims. In higher education, under principles of academic freedom that have been widely endorsed, professors are entitled to freedom in the classroom in discussing their subject. Educators, not politicians, should make decisions about teaching and learning.

Knowledge of the past exists to serve the needs of the living. In the current context, this includes an honest reckoning with all aspects of that past. Americans of all ages deserve nothing less than a free and open exchange about history and the forces that shape our world today, an exchange that should take place inside the classroom as well as in the public realm generally. To ban the tools that enable those discussions is to deprive us all of the tools necessary for citizenship in the twenty-first century. A white-washed view of history cannot change what happened in the past. A free and open society depends on the unrestricted pursuit and dissemination of knowledge.


American Association of University Professors

American Historical Association

Association of American Colleges & Universities

PEN America

The following organizations have co-signed this statement:

ACPA-College Student Educators International

Agricultural History Society

Alcohol and Drugs History Society

American Anthropological Association

American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education

American Council of Learned Societies

American Educational Research Association

American Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO

American Folklore Society

American Library Association

American Philosophical Association

American Political Science Association

American Society for Environmental History

American Society for Theatre Research

American Sociological Association

American Studies Association

Anti-Defamation League

Association for Ancient Historians

Association for Asian American Studies

Association for Documentary Editing

Association for Spanish and Portuguese Historical Studies

Association for the Study of Higher Education

Association for Theatre in Higher Education

Association of College and Research Libraries

Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges

Association of Research Libraries

Association of University Presses

Association of Writers & Writing Programs

Business History Conference

Center for Research Libraries

Central European History Society

Chinese Historians in the United States

Coalition of Urban & Metropolitan Universities (CUMU)

College Art Association

Committee on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, & Transgender History

Comparative and International Education Society

Conference on Asian History

Conference on Faith and History

Consortium of Humanities Centers and Institutes

Czechoslovak Studies Association

Forum on Early-Modern Empires and Global Interactions

Freedom to Read Foundation

French Colonial Historical Society

German Studies Association

Hispanic Association of Colleges and Universities

Historical Society of Twentieth Century China

Immigration Ethnic History Society

John N. Gardner Institute for Excellence in Undergraduate Education

Labor and Working-Class History Association

Middle East Studies Association

Modern Language Association

NAFSA: Association of International Educators

National Association for College Admission Counseling

National Association for Equal Opportunity in Higher Education

National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education

National Coalition for History

National Council for the Social Studies

National Council of Teachers of English

National Council on Public History

National Women's Studies Association

Organization of American Historians

Phi Beta Kappa Society

Radical History Review

Rhetoric Society of America

Roy Rosenzweig Center for History and New Media

Shakespeare Association of America

Society for Austrian and Habsburg History

Society for Classical Studies

Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era

Society for the Study of Early Modern Women and Gender

Society of Architectural Historians

Society of Civil War Historians

Southern Historical Association

Urban History Association

Western History Association

World History Association